Jarin des Plantes, Paris
His gaze, going past those bars, has got so misted
with tiredness, it can take in nothing more.
He feels as though a thousand bars existed,
and no more world beyond them than before.
Those supply powerful paddings, turning there
in tiniest of circles, well might be
the dance of forces round a centre where
some mighty will stands paralyticly.
Just now and then the pupils' noiseless shutter
if lifted. - Then an image with indart,
down throught the limbs' intensive stillness flutter,
and end its being in the heart.
with tiredness, it can take in nothing more.
He feels as though a thousand bars existed,
and no more world beyond them than before.
Those supply powerful paddings, turning there
in tiniest of circles, well might be
the dance of forces round a centre where
some mighty will stands paralyticly.
Just now and then the pupils' noiseless shutter
if lifted. - Then an image with indart,
down throught the limbs' intensive stillness flutter,
and end its being in the heart.
Rainer Maria Rilke Paris, 1903
(unidentified web translation)
Good idea to juxtapose the two translations. It makes the point!
ReplyDeleteIt made me think of the pitfalls of translation, and of how, in the process, the translator who starts with gold (Rilke’s poem) has to try her/ his best to avoid turning it into base metal.
Thanks Stella, It startles me again to read this juxtaposition. No wonder I didn't "get" Rilke when I first encountered him. The Snow translations make him come alive here in 2010.
ReplyDeleteThe Snow translation is so much the better one. And yet it makes me ask, is the poem Snow's or Rilke's?
ReplyDeleteHi Maureen -- that is the question for all translation. It's a fascinating subject. Jane Hirshfield has an excellent essay on the subject in her collection of essays 9 Gates (9?) and the Neruda translator Alistair ??? has a fabulous memoir on his life lived in translation. For me, the answer has to be it belongs to both of them. I've read dozens of Rilke translations (Mitchell, Norton, etc) and the poems change dramatically with each one.
ReplyDelete